The Trust Factor: How Leaders Build—and Rebuild—Trust with Their Teams

Tiffanie Fennell
Jun 30
2 min read

Trust is the foundation of every high‑performing team. Without it, disengagement, miscommunication, and even fear creep in. With it, you unlock loyalty, innovation, and collective success. In this post, we’ll explore what trust really means in leadership, how to establish it from day one, and how to rebuild it if it’s been broken.

What Trust Really Means in Leadership

Dependability: Your team needs to know you’ll follow through on commitments—big and small.
Authenticity: Honest communication, especially when the news is tough, builds credibility.
Consistency: Aligning your actions with your words shows you’re reliable and fair.

3 Ways to Build Trust from Day One

Be Consistently Reliable
- Communicate clear expectations.
- Deliver on your promises—on time, every time.
Practice Radical Transparency
- Share context on decisions, even if it’s not great news.
- Admit what you don’t know, and bring the team along as you learn.
Respect Existing Strengths
- Listen more than you talk.
- Acknowledge what your team already does well before proposing changes.

A 4‑Step Framework for Rebuilding Broken Trust

Acknowledge the Mistake
- Own it without excuses: “I understand how I let you down.”
Listen Actively
- Create safe space for honest feedback. No defensiveness—just empathy.
Commit to Meaningful Change
- Ask, “What can I do to make this right?” and then follow through.
Demonstrate Consistency Over Time
- Trust isn’t rebuilt overnight—it’s earned day by day.

Common Trust‑Killers to Watch For

Micromanagement: Signals you don’t trust your team’s abilities.
Inconsistency: Saying one thing and doing another erodes credibility.
Favoritism: Even a hint of unfairness will poison team morale.

Leading with Trust Every Day

Trust isn’t a one‑off goal—it’s a daily practice. Small actions like admitting you were wrong, giving credit first, and simply asking “How can I lead you better?” reinforce your integrity and invite your team to follow your example.

Conclusion

Whether you’re establishing a new team dynamic or repairing a fractured relationship, remember: trust is a verb. It’s built through intentional actions, reinforced by consistency, and earned—not demanded. Start today by choosing one small behavior that shows you’re committed to trust—and keep building from there.

Want support with this or other leadership and personal development goals? Book a free 30-minute consultation session with me to discuss your goals, challenges, and vision for the future. We'll determine if my coaching approach aligns with your needs and if we're a good fit to work together.